Joined: 09 Jul 2005 Posts: 497 Location: Taunton, UK
Posted: Fri Aug 18, 2006 3:35 pm Post subject: How certain are we of the sounds assigned to hieroglyphs?
Even if the specialists have got it right what about dialects and changes over time.
For example classical Greek Beta now seems to be Veta and I can hardly understand someone speaking broad Geordie despite being born about the width of the Nile delta away.
What made me think of it was reading a site mentioned in an earlier post that said Wa-set (Thebes) might have been Set-wa and given rise to the Greek name & to Sheba.
You bring up a very good point. I think anyone of the 'experts' would agree that the pronunciations are at best an educated guess. Egyptian has been a dead language for over two thousand years. Its closest current languages in terms of pronunciation and meaning are Coptic and possibly Arabic. From these two languages scholars have based the possible pronunciations of the Ancient Egyptian language. Remember Champollion broke the code by comparing Coptic and the cartouche of Ramses (II). Since the language does not represent vowels in its heiroglyphic form, one must fill them in. Of course this is in large part where the guess work comes into play.
However, some claim that the language has just evolved and is still spoken today by Fellahins of Upper Egypt.
Also if we think of the span of the AE civilization of over 3000 years and the exposure and integration of other civilizations, friendly or not, there would certainly have been amalgamations and dialectal variations. Thus we would expect a difference in Old Egyptian to Middle Egyptian to Late Egyptian spoken language as we see in the written forms. _________________
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum